Bitching about the Commaders vine

Got a complaint to get off your chest? Post it here! Post count is off
Forum rules
Forum Specific Rules
Non Board Related Complaints Only. For Member To Member/Staff Complaints PM The Moderators.
User avatar
deadone
That Was Just Your Thousandth Post
Posts: 1740
Joined: Tue Jul 31, 2007 11:23 pm
Location: corby northamtonshire UK
Country: United Kingdom

Re: Bitching about the Commaders vine

Post by deadone »

agreed paul, maybe he will learn a lesson, dont matter how good or bad you alter a show some1 in the trading community is going to find out.
as for not being able to take screenshots lmfao.....
it wouldnt of been that bad if he altered his own recording and screwed it up but using some1 elses, well thats lame as far as im concerned.
anyway i did manage to get both shows anyway from a trade here and im just waiting for it to arrive.

o well his loss as members are gonna think twice before they trade with him again.

mick
User avatar
norbinho
Stone Cold Poster
Posts: 7615
Joined: Tue Sep 09, 2003 7:48 am
Location: Tyrol, Austria
Country: Austria

Re: Bitching about the Commaders vine

Post by norbinho »

Metfan72 wrote: Hey Mick, I too traded for the London because out of everyone that wanted the Sheffield show he is the only one who refused to send a list.

Just kept pushing the London show on me. So in the end, both you & I traded for these shows as he was not offering anything else, just pushing these shows that he altered.

And that is why he refused to put setlists and screens for anyone to see in the vine sign up thread and would not verify sources.

Claims to not know how to take screens but can put LiveMet to a show and watermark it? Someone get me a shovel.
good point, paul :thumbs-up:

didn't know he was trading out these low quality shows :o i would have been more then pissed if i had gotten this rubbish in a trade!! :hit:

PS: his list isn't spectacular at all <_<
Ride The Lightning Until It Sleeps!!
TheMechanixxx83 Channel

Norbinho on Tour 2019
Metallica
2019-05-08 Milano
2019-05-10 Zurich
2019-06-13 Cologne
2019-08-16 Vienna
2019-08-18 Prague
2019-08-21 Warsaw
2019-08-23 Munich
2019-08-25 Mannheim
User avatar
Metfan72
That Was Just Your Thousandth Post
Posts: 1573
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2008 2:44 am
Location: Ontario
Country: Canada

Re: Bitching about the Commaders vine

Post by Metfan72 »

What is worse is that after I finally said OK send the London show, then he tells me he is thinking about making a vine.

As it is, I now have 4 different versions of the same show.

I have the original, 2 copies of Andy's because the vine stopped at me, Michael's, and one that was made by NYCBC which is laughable at best.

The guys put the wrong date on the menu. They told me it was 2009-03-28, but sent me 2009-03-02 but the menu says 2009-03-22 and Metallica never played a show on that night.

So as you can imagine, this one show has been nothing but a headache for me.
Blood, Sweat, RESPECT!!
User avatar
norbinho
Stone Cold Poster
Posts: 7615
Joined: Tue Sep 09, 2003 7:48 am
Location: Tyrol, Austria
Country: Austria

Re: Bitching about the Commaders vine

Post by norbinho »

Metfan72 wrote: What is worse is that after I finally said OK send the London show, then he tells me he is thinking about making a vine.

As it is, I now have 4 different versions of the same show.

I have the original, 2 copies of Andy's because the vine stopped at me, Michael's, and one that was made by NYCBC which is laughable at best.

The guys put the wrong date on the menu. They told me it was 2009-03-28, but sent me 2009-03-02 but the menu says 2009-03-22 and Metallica never played a show on that night.

So as you can imagine, this one show has been nothing but a headache for me.
horrible, paul :o
Ride The Lightning Until It Sleeps!!
TheMechanixxx83 Channel

Norbinho on Tour 2019
Metallica
2019-05-08 Milano
2019-05-10 Zurich
2019-06-13 Cologne
2019-08-16 Vienna
2019-08-18 Prague
2019-08-21 Warsaw
2019-08-23 Munich
2019-08-25 Mannheim
User avatar
hellawaits77
That Was Just Your Thousandth Post
Posts: 2816
Joined: Mon Dec 31, 2007 2:47 am
Location: Upstate New York, USA
Country: United States

Re: Bitching about the Commaders vine

Post by hellawaits77 »

Metfan72 wrote: What is worse is that after I finally said OK send the London show, then he tells me he is thinking about making a vine.

As it is, I now have 4 different versions of the same show.

I have the original, 2 copies of Andy's because the vine stopped at me, Michael's, and one that was made by NYCBC which is laughable at best.

The guys put the wrong date on the menu. They told me it was 2009-03-28, but sent me 2009-03-02 but the menu says 2009-03-22 and Metallica never played a show on that night.

So as you can imagine, this one show has been nothing but a headache for me.
The NYCBC has a version of this show? Can you give me some more info?
Image
My Trading Page - Webs.com changed something, it looks terrible
My YouTube Channel
My Filming Blog
Trade Status : Very selective. PM me

07/20/03 - Montreal
01/18/09 - Boston
02/01/09 - Newark
09/20/09 - Montreal
11/12/09 - Albany
09/14/11 - Bronx
12/09/11 - SF
12/10/11 - SF
06/23/12 - Atlantic City
06/24/12 - Atlantic City
08/09/14 - Montreal
07/19/17 - Montreal
10/29/18 - Albany
User avatar
scottph
Phantom Lord
Posts: 820
Joined: Sun Jan 25, 2004 10:58 pm
Location: Munich
Country: Germany

Re: Bitching about the Commaders vine

Post by scottph »

Wow...just wow...
Scott
St. Germany - local chapter 273 of the official Metallica club.
http://www.st-germany.de
Thierry
The Unforgiven
Posts: 363
Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2003 12:52 pm
Location: Doetinchem
Country: Netherlands

Re: Bitching about the Commaders vine

Post by Thierry »

Bloody hell - what a bullshit. To be fairly honest you cannot put a watermark or even re-encode footage that has been recorded by somebody else. It's disrespectful.

But that's just my 2 cent.
Last edited by Thierry on Mon May 25, 2009 1:00 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Metfan72
That Was Just Your Thousandth Post
Posts: 1573
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2008 2:44 am
Location: Ontario
Country: Canada

Re: Bitching about the Commaders vine

Post by Metfan72 »

hellawaits77 wrote:
Metfan72 wrote: What is worse is that after I finally said OK send the London show, then he tells me he is thinking about making a vine.

As it is, I now have 4 different versions of the same show.

I have the original, 2 copies of Andy's because the vine stopped at me, Michael's, and one that was made by NYCBC which is laughable at best.

The guys put the wrong date on the menu. They told me it was 2009-03-28, but sent me 2009-03-02 but the menu says 2009-03-22 and Metallica never played a show on that night.

So as you can imagine, this one show has been nothing but a headache for me.
The NYCBC has a version of this show? Can you give me some more info?
Not an official NYCBC release. I got to talking to one of the filmers and he had said that he was getting London 2009-03-28 in. In the end it was 2009-03-02, but whoever made it for them messed up the menu. So it is not really a NYCBC release, just a buddy that sent it to them and they re-authored it.
Blood, Sweat, RESPECT!!
User avatar
Bluefalcon
That Was Just Your Thousandth Post
Posts: 1415
Joined: Tue Jan 27, 2004 4:54 am
Location: Australia
Country: Australia

Re: Bitching about the Commaders vine

Post by Bluefalcon »

Wow, I have'nt had time to keep up to speed on what's gone on lately but it appears that the shit has hit the fan regarding these vined shows. What's the final story?, should I just toss these versions in the bin and not list them?.
User avatar
Metfan72
That Was Just Your Thousandth Post
Posts: 1573
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2008 2:44 am
Location: Ontario
Country: Canada

Re: Bitching about the Commaders vine

Post by Metfan72 »

Bluefalcon wrote: Wow, I have'nt had time to keep up to speed on what's gone on lately but it appears that the shit has hit the fan regarding these vined shows. What's the final story?, should I just toss these versions in the bin and not list them?.
Yeah it has hit the fan.

Nobody in their right mind is going to list them. As soon as they got to me, I didn't even bother opening the package you sent me, I just tossed them.

You can keep them and view them if you want, but they shouldn't really be freely distributed.

What he did was dirty and he has been punished for it. Let's see if he actually learns anything from it.
Blood, Sweat, RESPECT!!