Master of Puppets Song Game

[Cookiez]

ONLY CHANGE 2 SONGS: +1 TO YOUR FAVORITE; -1 TO YOUR LEAST FAVORITE
AND REMEMBER: THE TOTAL OF ALL POINTS HAS TO BE 80!!!

2. Master Of Puppets 51+1=52
4. Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 15
7. Orion 14-1=13

Eliminated songs in the order they were given the axe:

1. The Thing That Should Not Be
2. Leper Messiah
3. Disposable Heroes
4. Damage, Inc.
5. Battery

[Phantom_Lord_GER]

ONLY CHANGE 2 SONGS: +1 TO YOUR FAVORITE; -1 TO YOUR LEAST FAVORITE
AND REMEMBER: THE TOTAL OF ALL POINTS HAS TO BE 80!!!

2. Master Of Puppets 52+1=53
4. Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 15
7. Orion 13-1=12

Eliminated songs in the order they were given the axe:

1. The Thing That Should Not Be
2. Leper Messiah
3. Disposable Heroes
4. Damage, Inc.
5. Battery

[unforgiven]

ONLY CHANGE 2 SONGS: +1 TO YOUR FAVORITE; -1 TO YOUR LEAST FAVORITE
AND REMEMBER: THE TOTAL OF ALL POINTS HAS TO BE 80!!!

2. Master Of Puppets 53+1=54
4. Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 15
7. Orion 12-1=11

Eliminated songs in the order they were given the axe:

1. The Thing That Should Not Be
2. Leper Messiah
3. Disposable Heroes
4. Damage, Inc.
5. Battery

[koopee27]

i guess we can all agree that "Master of Puppets" is the winner.

so from this point on we will vote for the 2nd place to get this finished soon.

ONLY CHANGE 2 SONGS: +1 TO YOUR FAVORITE; -1 TO YOUR LEAST FAVORITE
AND REMEMBER: THE TOTAL OF ALL POINTS HAS TO BE 80!!!

2. Master Of Puppets WINNER
4. Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 15-1=14
7. Orion 11+1=12

Eliminated songs in the order they were given the axe:

1. The Thing That Should Not Be
2. Leper Messiah
3. Disposable Heroes
4. Damage, Inc.
5. Battery

[no leaf clover]

No, just like the KEA game we'll play it to the very end.

ONLY CHANGE 2 SONGS: +1 TO YOUR FAVORITE; -1 TO YOUR LEAST FAVORITE
AND REMEMBER: THE TOTAL OF ALL POINTS HAS TO BE 80!!!

2. Master Of Puppets 54-1=53
4. Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 14
7. Orion 12+1=13

Eliminated songs in the order they were given the axe:

1. The Thing That Should Not Be
2. Leper Messiah
3. Disposable Heroes
4. Damage, Inc.
5. Battery

[Sailing home]

No, just like the KEA game we'll play it to the very end.

ONLY CHANGE 2 SONGS: +1 TO YOUR FAVORITE; -1 TO YOUR LEAST FAVORITE
AND REMEMBER: THE TOTAL OF ALL POINTS HAS TO BE 80!!!

2. Master Of Puppets 53-1=52
4. Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 14+1=15
7. Orion 13

Eliminated songs in the order they were given the axe:

1. The Thing That Should Not Be
2. Leper Messiah
3. Disposable Heroes
4. Damage, Inc.
5. Battery

[koopee27]

No, just like the KEA game we'll play it to the very end.

give me one good reason why? for example "welcome home" has had 14-16 points for the last 3-4 weeks. this way this will never end.

kp

[no leaf clover]

Because what's the point of playing games when members change the rules during a game by themselves?

The least one can do is to propose a change of rules or something so that everybody can agree. Something like Pete-Rock did in the KEA game.

Something similar can be done here too but it can't be the decision of just one.

[koopee27]

sorry that i stepped in your playground.

i hereby propose that we either call this game finished: Master Of Puppets is winner and 2nd place is a tie between Orion & Welcome Home
or we try to settle who takes the 2nd place..

or we play this forever..

any thoughts?

kp

[no leaf clover]

First of all: this is not my playground. This is everybody's playground.

My reply wasn't meant to give you that impression.

I agree with you that these games take very long. Maybe we can add a new rule to prevent that.

I don't mind calling MOP as the winner and try to settle which song will take 2nd place.

I don't mind a change of rules as long as every participant knows them.