1989-05-17 - Osaka, Japan

[sousourn1823]

Need some help with this show :

for me, the 1st source is an audience recording.

Where Muder Lies
Venue: @Koseinenkin Hall : Osaka, Japan
Date: May 17, 1989
Time: 147:08
Size: 2 CDs
Sound: AUD
Notes: Source : Copy from Silver 2CD

1st source and longest version.

01. Opening SE / The Ecstasy of Gold
02. Blackened
03. For Whom The Bell Tolls
04. Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
05. The Four Horsemen
06. Harvester Of Sorrow
07. Eye of the Beholder
08. Jason Newsted Bass Solo / To Live is to Die
09. Master Of Puppets
10. One

01. Seek and Destroy
02. And Justice For All
03. How Many More Times
04. Creeping Death
05. Fade to Black
06. Kirk Hammet Solo
07. Battery
08. Garage Medley
09. Am I Evil ?
10. Whiplash
11. Breadfan

https://mega.nz/folder/BFUCwLob#IriMg6z2vX_jvJfu8j1TGA

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
this one and the next ones are supposed from soundboard recording, they sound similar to the metvault version (mp3)
let me know what you think :

Welcome to the Fun Palace
Venue: @Koseinenkin Hall : Osaka, Japan
Date: May 17, 1989
Time: 121:30
Size: 2 CDs
Sound: SDB
Notes: Source : Copy from Silver 2CD

Soundboard version, shorter than source 1

01. Blackened
02. For Whom The Bell Tolls
03. Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
04. The Four Horsemen
05. Harvester Of Sorrow
06. Eye of the Beholder
07. Jason Newsted Bass Solo
08. To Live is to Die
09. Master Of Puppets
10. One
11. Seek and Destroy

01. And Justice For All
02. How Many More Times
03. Creeping Death
04. Fade to Black
05. Kirk Hammet Solo
06. Little Wing
07. Battery
08. Symptom of the Universe
09. The Prowler
10. Run to the Hills
11. The Frayed Ends of Sanity
12. The Wait
13. Last Caress
14. Am I Evil ?
15. Whiplash
16. Breadfan

https://mega.nz/folder/ANVCmB7L#6ovpUE7D8JjN4kYWayA_LA

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
LOSSY recording

Venue: @Koseinenkin Hall : Osaka, Japan
Date: May 17, 1989
Time: 131:24
Size: 2 CDs
Sound: SDB LOSSY
Notes: Version 4


Blackened
For Whom the Bell Tolls
Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
The Four Horsemen
Harvester of Sorrow
Eye of The Beholder
Bass Solo
To Live is To Die jam
Master of Puppets
One
Seek And Destroy
... And Justice For All
Smoke on the Water / How Many More Times / Black Night jam
Creeping Death
Fade to Black
Guitar Solo
Battery
Frayed Ends of Sanity / Phantom of the Opera / Prowler jam
Run to the Hills / Helpless jam
The Wait
Last Caress
Am I Evil?
Whiplash
Breadfan

https://mega.nz/folder/4McklJTC#Xit8vyxBttumPGqoBruk2w

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
@Koseinenkin Hall : Osaka, Japan
May 17, 1989
129:34

Source : Unknown gen tape from Stef's collection
Transfer : 2x audio tapes TDK AD90 > Denon Stereo Cassette Tape Deck DR-M11 > E-MU 0404 PCI Card > Wavelab 6 > .wav > flac
Transferred by sousourn1823 - July 2016

Correct show : yes, James makes reference to Osaka and being the 2nd night after Welcome Home. Setlist matches too.


The Ecstasy of Gold
Blackened
For Whom the Bell Tolls
Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
The Four Horsemen
Harvester of Sorrow
Eye of The Beholder
Bass Solo
To Live is To Die jam
Master of Puppets
One
Seek And Destroy
... And Justice For All
Smoke on the Water / How Many More Times / Black Night jam
Creeping Death
Fade to Black
Guitar Solo
Battery
Frayed Ends of Sanity / Phantom of the Opera / Prowler / Run to the Hills / Helpless jam
The Wait
Last Caress
Am I Evil?
Whiplash
Breadfan

https://mega.nz/folder/xRd00JLZ#KB8PS96Vbl26TQgOsVnxbg

[leomet_2000]

i think there is no a SBD version of this show... METVAULT have a lot of of audience recordings

[omitfyt]

THX for sharing. This show was listed as a SBD one many times, thats right.

[newsthet]

It seems that I have different version then those:
It sounds SBD to me I've never heard AUD show that good.

1989-05-17 Koseinkin Hall Osaka Japan 16bit SB

https://mega.nz/file/ZAJT1QiZ#neAmTfIlP ... 8e3l0wCBPs

From the info file:

Metallica 1989 May 17 Koseinkin Hall Osaka Japan

SOUNDBOARD

cassette sony HF90min>>>unknown gen>>SONY TAPE DECK>>>Goldwave>>RAW SOUND FILE>>>FLAC>>YOU

Setlist:
1-Intro
2-blackened
3-for whom the bell tolls
4-welcome home sanitarium
5-Four horsemen
6-harvester of sorrow
7-eye of the beholder
8-bass solo(to live is to die)
***tape flip***
9-Master of puppets
10-one
11-seek and destroy
12-and justice for all
13-how many more times
14 creeping death
15-fade to black
16-guitar solo
***TAPE FLIP***
17 little wings+Kirk's solo
18-battery
19-frayed end of sanity+prowler
20-run to the hills+helpless
21-the wait
22-last caress
23-am i evil
24-whiplash
25-breadfan

[leomet_2000]

It seems that I have different version then those:
It sounds SBD to me I've never heard AUD show that good.

1989-05-17 Koseinkin Hall Osaka Japan 16bit SB

https://mega.nz/file/ZAJT1QiZ#neAmTfIlP ... 8e3l0wCBPs

From the info file:

Metallica 1989 May 17 Koseinkin Hall Osaka Japan

SOUNDBOARD

cassette sony HF90min>>>unknown gen>>SONY TAPE DECK>>>Goldwave>>RAW SOUND FILE>>>FLAC>>YOU

Setlist:
1-Intro
2-blackened
3-for whom the bell tolls
4-welcome home sanitarium
5-Four horsemen
6-harvester of sorrow
7-eye of the beholder
8-bass solo(to live is to die)
***tape flip***
9-Master of puppets
10-one
11-seek and destroy
12-and justice for all
13-how many more times
14 creeping death
15-fade to black
16-guitar solo
***TAPE FLIP***
17 little wings+Kirk's solo
18-battery
19-frayed end of sanity+prowler
20-run to the hills+helpless
21-the wait
22-last caress
23-am i evil
24-whiplash
25-breadfan

this is audience, remember Tokyo 15/3 sounds awesome and is just audience..... for me this is audience, you can clearly heard people screaming during the songs, may be is not that clear since have a lot of tape hiss

[leomet_2000]

track17 little wings+kirks solo

on this track you can heard people clapping, and Metallica SBD FROM THAT ERA HAVE NO CROWD..... anyways if this have crowd.... you can clearly hear clapping on this oine when it starts

[newsthet]

track17 little wings+kirks solo

on this track you can heard people clapping, and Metallica SBD FROM THAT ERA HAVE NO CROWD..... anyways if this have crowd.... you can clearly hear clapping on this oine when it starts

I hear the crowed even at other songs but it sound very pro recording, I just don't get how AUD recording can be that good.

[trifaz]

Thank you

[M4ST3R M1K3]

I think all the links posted above are audience. I also have another bootleg that sounds very similar (hiss) to the one posted by newshet, but in 3 big files.

All but one are from the same recording. "Where Muder Lies" is a different recording. On this one, the taper is nearer the audience, the screams are different, and much louder.

[sousourn1823]

I think all the links posted above are audience. I also have another bootleg that sounds very similar (hiss) to the one posted by newshet, but in 3 big files.

All but one are from the same recording. "Where Muder Lies" is a different recording. On this one, the taper is nearer the audience, the screams are different, and much louder.

Thanks Mike, so to resume :

Source 1 : copy from Silver 2CD - WHERE MURDER LIES

Source 2 / version 1 : copy from Silver 2CD - WELCOME TO THE FUN PALACE
Source 2 / version 2 : from Metvault
Source 2 / version 3 : Lossy
Source 2 / version 4 : my tape rip

2 differents audience recordinigs.

the newsthet one is from source 2 too ?